How to Compare between Laser Engraving and CNC Stone Engraving Machine?-smtstonemachine.com

How to Compare between Laser Engraving and CNC Stone Engraving Machine?

July 25 , 2025

Engraving technology plays a significant role in modern personalised customisation and industrial manufacturing. Laser engraving and CNC stone engraving are two mainstream engraving methods, each with its unique advantages and application scenarios. We will delve into the core differences between these two technologies to help you make an informed choice based on your project requirements.

Core Technology Principles Comparison

Laser engraving technology utilises high-energy-density laser beams to induce physical or chemical changes on the material surface, achieving engraving effects through precise control of the laser path. This non-contact processing method is particularly suitable for intricate patterns and complex designs.

CNC stone carving employs three-axis or five-axis CNC machines equipped with specialised stone cutting tools or diamond needles. It removes material through physical cutting to achieve carving effects on stone surfaces.
Carving effects are achieved through milling and grinding.

Differences in Material Compatibility

Laser engraving compatible materials
Optimal materials: wood, acrylic, leather, glass, anodised aluminium, certain plastics.
Limited effectiveness on materials: transparent materials (requiring special treatment), certain reflective metals.
Not suitable for materials: chlorine-containing materials (e.g., PVC), certain materials that release toxic gases.

CNC stone carving specialises in
Natural stone: marble, granite, limestone, slate, sandstone, etc.
Engineered stone: quartz stone, engineered marble, concrete products.
Other hard materials: can also be used on hardwood, metal, etc., but the primary advantage lies in stone applications .

Processing Precision and Detail Reproduction

Laser engraving advantages:
Ultra-high precision: capable of 0.01mm-level detail.
Microscopic control: suitable for complex patterns and fine text (minimum font size of 0.5mm).
Non-contact processing: avoids errors caused by material displacement.
Production efficiency: quickly completes flat patterns without tool changes.
CNC engraving characteristics:
Typical precision: around 0.1mm, limited by tool size.
Three-dimensional representation: excels at 3D engraving with varying depths.
Large-scale works: more suitable for large-sized stone carving (e.g., tombstones, architectural decorations).
Production efficiency: suitable for large-scale stone processing, but tool changes take time.

Finished product effect and artistic expression

Laser engraving characteristics: Typically retains the original colour of the material, creating contrast through burning. Can achieve effects from shallow markings to deep engraving, but may be limited on stone. Can achieve gradient effects and grayscale image reproduction.

CNC engraving artistry: True 3D engraving, capable of expressing different depth levels with strong three-dimensionality. Can achieve various effects such as sandblasting and polishing through different tools. Suitable for large-scale artistic creations such as monuments and architectural reliefs.

Health, Safety, and Environmental Considerations

Laser engraving precautions: Requires a professional exhaust system to handle gases produced during engraving. Some materials may produce harmful substances during engraving, so laser safety equipment must be provided.

CNC stone engraving considerations: High noise levels require soundproofing measures. Stone dust is produced, so a dust collection system is needed. High-speed rotating tools require safety guards.

Laser engraving and CNC stone engraving each have their advantages. The choice depends on your specific materials, design requirements, and budget. Laser technology is evolving toward higher power levels, potentially expanding into more stone application areas. CNC engraving machines are developing toward multi-axis linkage and intelligent directions. The two may overlap and integrate in certain application scenarios.

Следующий :
Как лучше всего резать тонкий каменный шпон, не допуская появления трещин?

Категории

блог

Новый блог

Теги